What do you really know about Medicare?
Since Mitt Romney selected Paul Ryan as his Vice Presidential candidate there has been a lot of talk in the media about Medicare and Medicaid. A lot of what is being said about these federal programs is wrong. This is a very basic overview of one of the more complex programs that is administered by the government. Most people who do not use the program have no idea how it works. In this brief primer I will try to provide some facts which may make these programs easier to understand. I hope this will also help to refute some of the more inane arguments against these programs that are sure to be trotted out in the coming months.
++++++++++++++++++++++
Medicare and Medicaid fall under the authority of the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS). The specific agency responsible for overseeing the two programs is the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). For Fiscal Year ending September 30, 2011 CMS had outlays of approximately 767 billion dollars (total expenses for 2011 exceeded 817 billion), or, approximately 21% of total Federal outlays. As of 2011 49 million beneficiaries were enrolled in Medicare and 56 million people were enrolled in Medicaid. The total Federal outlays for Social Security in 2011 were 787 billion.
What is the difference between Medicare and Medicaid?
In 1965 Medicare was created as a supplemental program to Social Security. Generally, Medicare covers people aged 65 or older. While the majority of Medicare beneficiaries are 65 or older, the program has been expanded to provide coverage to several other categories. People who are experiencing End Stage Renal Disease are eligible for Medicare. Individuals who qualify for Social Security Disability will qualify for Medicare 24 months after they are awarded disability status. The most recently added category has been for individuals who have been diagnosed with Lou Gehrig’s disease. People with Lou Gehrig’s disease are eligible for Medicare one month after they are awarded disability.
Medicaid is a means tested program that is run by each individual state but jointly funded with State and Federal dollars. The eligibility rules vary by state, but basically, Medicaid is for those individuals with incomes below 15 thousand dollars.
What is Medicare Part A, B, C and D?
There are four separate parts to the Medicare program. These are defined in general terms as follows: Medicare Part A covers inpatient hospitalization, Medicare Part B covers outpatient procedures, Medicare Part C is a Medicare Advantage plan (generally offering expanded benefits at a higher premium) which is run by a private company that has been approved by Medicare, and Medicare Part D is the prescription drug plan that was introduced in 2003.
How much does each part cost the beneficiary?
A person (or their spouse) needs 40 eligible work credits to be entitled to free Medicare Part A. A person can only earn 4 work credits a year. In 2012 a person earned one credit for each 1130 of total earnings per quarter. If a person has not earned enough lifetime work credits to be eligible for free Medicare Part A then they can purchase Part A coverage. For 2012 a person with 30-39 quarters will be charged 248 dollars a month for Part A, less than 30 quarters will cost 451 dollars a month. Medicare Part B is voluntary. Generally, everyone enrolled in Part B must pay a monthly premium. For the year 2012 the amount is 99.90. Medicare Part C and Medicare Part D are both administered by private companies that are approved by the government. Therefore, the premiums vary from plan to plan. It should be understood that both Part A and Part B have annual deductibles. The deductible for Part A is a little complex to calculate, but it is basically 1156 for the year. Medicare Part B is an 80/20 plan (Medicare will pay 80% of approved procedures with the beneficiary being billed the remaining 20%) with a 140 dollar deductible for 2012.
How many people work for Medicare?
There are approximately 5000 federal employees and roughly 30000 non-federal employees who administer the Medicare program.
How many claims are processed every year?
In 2011 more than 1 billion claims were processed by Medicare.
What is Medicare’s overhead?
The federal program operates with less than a 3% overhead margin.
My apologies if anyone found this too detailed. These are complex programs which serve a very vital role in today’s society. The importance of these programs cannot be over emphasized. Most of those who are talking about changing, or eliminating, these programs simply have no concept of what they actually do. When one considers the number of people enrolled in both programs one realizes that these programs cannot simply be eliminated. While there is always fraud committed by Medical providers, the low overhead margin of these programs indicates that there is very little administrative waste. Thanks for reading.
Comments
Cool, thanks.
We all should brush up on this. I think it's also helpful to overview the entire national budget for a perspective on the numbers the politicians are going to be talking about. Might be good to have a section on here with factoids about Medicare, SS, and the budget.
yeah, tell someone with ESRD to go get their own insurance
Thanks. I was a little worried that it would be too dry for anyone to read. These are remarkably important programs that are generally used by people with limited income. The market is not all things to all people. If someone has ESRD they will simply not be covered by normal insurance. Ryan's budget is not bold, it's just cruel.
Virtual rec!
Sometimes I just don't have time to comment and want a thumbs up option, so don't think your work here goes unnoticed. I am becoming a fan. Hopefully I won't turn into a stalker.
thanks
I'm at an age in my life when I think I finally have time for a stalker.......and I really do like your avatar.
And thank you for writing
Something that is often lied about is if and when Medicare will go into the red or how to prevent this popular program from going into the red.
I asked a question on the radio yesterday but failed to articulate my first part because of either nervousness or the fact that I didn't think I owned the program. Why would Paul Ryan want to wait until Americans turn 55? I know the most obvious answer, not losing voters over 56 but there was something practical where I wanted to go.
When do people under 55 become eligible for Medicare? Let us say, God forbid, the bill gets passed in 2013, making the first vouchered senior citizen in 2023. At that time the pool of Baby Boomers would be rapidly growing smaller because of natural endings, a newborn in 1946 would be 77 in a nation with a pretty low life expectancy. So Paul Ryan is focused on that time when what is most straining Medicare is curing itself. So by fixing Medicare after it is already fixing itself, there must be something else on his agenda.
The second part I articulated (at 11:19) well enough 'If you are going to set up a private pool for all the healthy seniors, isn't that going to end up with the sick seniors driving Medicare into incredible debt and we'll end up with republicans pounding their fist on the table screaming "Now we need to privatize the whole program."
I probably could have worded it better but it wouldn't have mattered. I was asking a talking points machine. Whenever I cal into a radio show I really empathize with the professionals who try to ask these people questions knowing they have no intention of ever acknowledging the question.
But I've got to figure that the end game in Ryan's long term plan is the privatizing of all of health coverage of our seniors and our poor. Actually it more like profit from seniors and fuck the poor.
Is Medicare too big too fail?
I meant to have a paragraph on the coming Medicare bankruptcy that is always shouted about by the very bold and very serious people that want to end the program. Every year Medicare issues a Financial Statement which includes a ridiculous 75 year trust fund projection. The 2011 projection stated that in a worse case scenario the Part A portion of the program would be insolvent by 2024-2026. Insolvent as in the money in the Part A trust fund would not be sufficient to pay all of the Part A medical claims. That is not the same as saying that there will be zero funds. The other three parts are self funding (premium driven) and are not in financial trouble. Oh, and Social Security will never go bankrupt if the the contribution cap is eliminated and benefits capped. These are easy fixes but no one wants to fix these programs, they want to eliminate them entirely. Raising the Medicare payroll tax 1 percent would bring these programs back into the black.
Perhaps you should add this comment to the main body.
This is very important information.
The privatization delusion fails on the most cursory examination. How likely is it that the same program can be run more cheaply with 30% or more profit skimmed off the top? It's an absurd notion.
Thanks for the info, Sartoris
Medicare is always "going bankrupt."
Since we issue our own currency, we can decide Medicare won't go bankrupt like the government could never go bankrupt. We can have years of painful costs, but if a trend is unsustainable it won't be sustained. Medicare advantage has 9% administrative costs compared to 2% for your grandfather's Medicare.
Medicare for all is the solution while ridding the private waste and overall private health care system that suckles off of it and dumps the most expensive patients onto Medicare because you can't get access to preventative care in a private system and even if you can like supposedly with the ACA now people won't go because the costs scare them too much.
Wow!
Thanks for this chart. I'll make use of it.
Anytime! :D
.
completely agree
I am in agreement with the idea of Medicare for all. Private insurance companies bring nothing to healthcare. Raise the payroll tax 1% on employees and 1% on employers and the programs will be fine.
Indeed, Sartoris!
This is the right debate/solution absent in Washington.